- Mark Postma, 63.1% – 1999
- Lucas Roetcisoender, 57.5% – 2015
- Greg Dykstra, 57.1% – 1997
- Scott Romjue, 56.1% – 1995
- Greg Dykstra, 55.5% – 1996
- Grant Terpstra, 54.7% – 1992
- Scott Romjue, 54.5% – 1994
- Grant Terpstra, 53.4% – 1993
- Jeremy Huntley, 53.4% – 2000
- Mark Holleman, 52.8% – 2002
- Lucas Roetcisoender, 52.7% – 2014
- Colby Flint, 52.5% – 2016
- Isaac Reimer, 51.9% – 2012
- Daniel Ten Broek, 51.8% – 2008
- Dan Kaemingk, 51.4% – 1979
Mark Postma