- Todd Stephan, 5 – 1977
- Tim Carlson, 5 – 1983
- Brian Langstraat, 3 – 1984
- Greg Brand, 2 – 1979
- Ken Roberts, 2 – 1983
- Darrell Stacey, 2 – 1986
- Brian Talley, 2 – 1987
- Jason Staeber, 2 – 1988
- Travis Ernst, 2 – 1992
- Zack Halverson, 2 – 2005
- Jeremy Rick, 2 – 2007
- J.T. Fitzgerald, 2 – 2007
- Oliver Dougherty, 2 – 2011
- Melvin Deal, 2 – 2013
- Multiple Players with 1
