- Joe Duffey, 40 – 1987
- Jon Christie, 34 – 1976
- Josh Bailey, 34 – 1995
- Walker Storrer, 30 – 2010
- Jace King, 30 – 2014
- Robbie Smith, 29 – 2002
- Ryan Johnson, 27 – 1993
- Joseph Worley, 27 – 2016
- Joseph Worley, 25 – 2015
- Joe Stuckrath, 23 – 2003
- Joe Stuckrath, 22 – 2004
- Walker Storrer, 21 – 2008
- Tony Frazier, 20 – 1982
- Brian Prouty, 20 – 1988
- Josh Bailey, 20 – 1994
- Kaleb Smartt, 20 – 2012
So cool to see Joe The Toe still on top! It’s still a travesty he only got NWL Second Team instead of First in 87. RIP bud!
RIP Joe. Great kicker better D and O lineman…