- Jaxon Ernst, 60.5% – 1991
- James Hinson, 58.9% – 2016
- Jake Locker, 58.7% – 2005
- James Hinson, 58.5% – 2017
- Casey Locker, 56.7% – 2008
- Mike Duncan, 55.1% – 2001
- Casey Locker, 54.8% – 2006
- Jaxon Ernst, 53.2% – 1992
- Casey Locker, 52.1% – 2007
- Mike Duncan, 50.6% – 2000
- Doug Pederson, 49.0% – 1985
- Jake Locker, 48.1% – 2004
- James Hinson, 47.4% – 2015
- Matt Beck, 46.9% – 1976
- Darin Nolan, 46.6% – 1986
