- Greg Dykstra, 5 vs. Blaine, 1997
- Kevin Bratt, 4 vs. Lakeside-Seattle, 1994
- Lance Bosman, 4 vs. Lakeside-Seattle, 1994
- Jeff Hoekstra, 4 vs. Blaine, 2003
- Kyle De Boer, 4 vs. Port Townsend, 2003
- Niels Brisbane, 4 vs. Cedar Park Christian, 2007
- Multiple players with 3
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/8b1de/8b1de2c3d5029d14e57ccf32c4db02f90f989a37" alt=""