- Izaiha Schwinden, 7 vs. LaCenter, 2013
- Jim Schleimer, 6 vs. Chimacum, 1998
- Jim Schleimer, 6 vs. South Whidbey, 1999
- Jed Schleimer, 6 vs. Nooksack Valley, 2015
- Joe Schleimer, 5 vs. Friday Harbor, 1996
- Jacob Prince, 5 vs. Granite Falls, 1997
- Mikel Rathjen, 5 vs. Sultan, 2002
- Levi Wigg, 5 vs. Blaine, 2010
- Levi Wigg, 5 vs. Squalicum, 2011
- Jed Schleimer, 5 vs. Sultan, 2015
- Multiple players with 4