- Casey Bauman, 64.6% – 2017
- Tanner Myhre, 64.2% – 2014
- Casey Bauman, 63.9% – 2016
- Tanner Myhre, 61.5% – 2012
- Tyler Perry, 61.4% – 2010
- Chris Mitchell, 61.3% – 2006
- Casey Bauman, 60.1% – 2015
- Tyler Perry, 59.3% – 2009
- Kyle Mitchell, 57.6% – 2003
- Tanner Myhre, 57.3% – 2013
- Darrin Van Weerdhuizen, 56.2% – 2002
- Trevon Myhre, 54.5% – 2011
- Wade Rediger, 53.9% – 2008
- Trevon Myhre, 52.4% – 2010
- Brandon Newell, 49.6% – 1989
