- Garrett Sorenson, 61.6% – 2016
- Christian Jorgensen, 61.0% – 2014
- Garrett Sorenson, 58.1% – 2015
- Clark Hazlett, 57.7% – 2013
- Graham Hovde, 54.1% – 2006
- Zach Victor, 54.1% – 2008
- Spencer Lloyd, 53.6% – 2017
- Quin Moore, 52.1% – 2009
- Keith Stackhouse, 48.8% – 2007
- Clark Hazlett, 47.9% – 2011
- Clark Hazlett, 46.9% – 2012
- Tyler Goodrich, 45.0% – 2010
- Tim James, 40.0% – 1998
- Aaron Dickson, 28.3% – 2003
